Start with concepts, then move to trial tests
"The right sequence is: learn the concept first, then apply it through practice."
The most common preparation mistake is doing practice papers before a student understands the underlying concepts.
A student who does not understand how to approach a Thinking Skills question will answer it incorrectly. If they then do another practice paper with the same question type, they will answer it incorrectly again. Repeating this does not build understanding. It builds the habit of getting it wrong. By the time a student arrives at the exam, they have practised the mistake dozens of times.
The right sequence is: learn the concept first, then apply it through practice. Once the concept is understood, timed practice papers serve their purpose: building speed, building confidence, and simulating exam conditions.
The only exception is if the exam is imminent and there is almost no time left. In that situation, working through practice papers to become familiar with the format is better than nothing. But the ideal is not to reach that point.
Which practice resources to trust
The quality of preparation materials varies widely. Using the wrong resources wastes time and, worse, teaches students incorrect approaches.
The most reliable starting point is the sample questions and practice tests published by the NSW Department of Education. Use the online practice tests, which work like the real computer-based test. The Department says its PDF practice tests come from the older paper test, so they do not show the current format.
Attempt them properly the first time: under timed conditions, without looking up answers mid-way. Working through the same questions a second or third time is not useful preparation. Students remember the specific wording and the answer rather than developing the underlying skill.
For additional practice, look for resources aligned to the current computer-based format. The Selective test was redesigned and moved to computers in recent years. Books written for the old paper-based format, including some still being sold today, do not reflect how the current exam works. If a resource was written before the move to computers, treat it with caution.
The Department's sample tests are copyright of Cambridge University Press & Assessment (NSW Department of Education, 2026). Materials built on that style are more likely to help than older generic books.
From what we have seen, many new selective preparation websites are not worth the time. A common problem is questions written by AI. They look believable but do not match the exam's structure, difficulty or question types. Students who spend a lot of time on these platforms may feel they are preparing well while practising for a different exam altogether.
The clearest signal of a quality resource is whether students who have sat the recent exam recognise the format and difficulty.
When in doubt, the Department of Education's own materials are the safest benchmark.
Use rankings, not raw scores
In the months before the exam, many students complete weekly or fortnightly trial tests through programs or tutoring providers. This helps, because your child practises the question types under time.
The number to pay attention to is not the raw score. It is the ranking.
A raw score (the mark itself) of 15 out of 25 in Writing might seem low. But suppose 100 students sat the same test that week and the average was 10 out of 25. Then a score of 15 puts your child in a strong position against the rest of the group. A raw score of 20 might look excellent. But if the test was easy and most students scored about the same, it tells you less than you think.
The difficulty of trial tests varies between providers and between weeks. A ranking tells you where a student sits relative to other students preparing for the same exam. That is the comparison that tells you most.
In our experience, look at your child's ranking if they want a school where many more students apply than there are places. A useful sign is placing in the top 10 to 15% of the students sitting the trial, week after week. If they are, they are in a competitive position. If they are consistently in the middle or lower half, the preparation plan needs to change. That might mean changing what they practise, how much time they spend, or which schools you list.
Prepare steadily, not in a rush
"A student who studies when they feel like it will study less than one who has a specific time blocked out each week. Intentions are not a plan."
Last-minute cramming does not work for the Selective test. The question variety across Reading, Mathematical Reasoning, Thinking Skills and Writing is too broad to master in a month, even with intensive study. In our experience, a child who has prepared steadily for 12 to 18 months is in a far stronger position than one who crammed for four to six weeks.
A student who learns something new each week and practises it consistently retains it. A student who covers the same ground in a shorter period often finds the earlier concepts have faded by the time the exam arrives.
A student who is strong in Mathematical Reasoning but weak in Reading is not well served by spending equal time on both. If practice does not target known weak spots, your child gets better at what they already do well, and the gap in the weak area stays the same. Use trial test rankings by section to identify where the most work is needed.
The writing section requires a typed response completed in 30 minutes (NSW Department of Education, 2026). Typed, timed writing takes more practice than most children expect. It improves over months, not weeks. Our guide to what decides the Selective Writing score covers how the section is marked and how to spend the thirty minutes.
A student who is exhausted from too much preparation will not do well on exam day, however much they have covered. Steady, moderate effort over time works better than a burst of hard work that ends in exhaustion.
How to choose your three schools
Your school choices matter as much as the preparation. You make them in the application, and you can change them until the Department's cut-off, which falls after the test. For entry in 2028, the last day is 25 June 2027 (NSW Department of Education, 2026).
Students can nominate up to three selective schools in order of preference (NSW Department of Education, 2026). Suppose your child has been placing in the top 20 to 25% of trial tests. Then listing only the schools where competition is fiercest leaves little room for error. A better list runs from a reach school (one your child might just get into) down to one where their results are more likely to be enough. That gives a better chance of an offer.
Two rules from the Department matter here. Listing a school first gives your child no extra consideration there. And you cannot turn down an offer to wait for a lower choice. So only list schools you would be glad for your child to attend.
Use trial test rankings and the Year 4 OC result to judge which schools to list. The OC result is a starting point. It shows where your child stood two years earlier, compared with a strong group of other children who sat the test.
1 on 1 or group tutoring?
Most families start by choosing between 1 on 1 and group tutoring. Both work. Which suits your child depends on how they learn.
1 on 1 tutoring
How it works
Every session is focused entirely on one student. Questions get addressed in the moment and the pace adjusts to where the student is.
Who it suits
- Students who need a concept explained multiple times before it clicks
- Students who are reserved or uncomfortable asking questions in front of others
- Students with uneven strengths across subjects
Group tutoring
How it works
A tutor teaches a class of students, usually following a fixed course at a set pace.
Who it suits
- Students who are quick to grasp new concepts and do not need extended explanation
- Students who benefit from peer learning or a structured class environment
Other advantages
- Generally more affordable than 1 on 1
- Often comes with more pre-prepared resources and practice material
The key caveat on group tutoring is class size. The smaller the group, the more personalised the attention each student gets. In our experience, a group of two to four works much better for exam preparation than a full class.
The test is sat on a computer. Whichever kind of tutoring you choose, make sure your child also practises on screen, under time, before May.